Some Aussie expats in the US have found themselves so desperate for a jar of Vegemite, they’ve been making their own.

Typically, Aussie expats living the US get Vegemite two ways – friends visiting from Australia who bring a big jar with them, or a specialty shop (if they stock it at all).

And yes, while you can get it online, places like Amazon sell Vegemite for roughly $US15 for a small 150g jar. That works out to be just over $AU20 in Aussie dollars, plus shipping.

Essentially, Vegemite is a luxury item.

And some expats have resorted to making their own.

“I’m so excited, I just made my own vegemite,” wrote a member on an Australians living in America Facebook group.

“I would say it’s not 100% like the store bought, but it’s a really good substitute.”


She posted the recipe, from a Thermomix community, and a photo of her finished product:


The poster said she “got tired of waiting for Covid to be over so people could visit, and we were feeling really homesick over the weekend, so I decided it was time to give this a go.”

The comments were pretty supportive, but you could almost feel the inner conflict.

  • ‘Wow I actually never thought to even attempt this’
  • ‘looks dangerous LOL’
  • ‘I’m not a vegemite fan nor a cooking fan in general hahaha but this shows true Aussie ingenuity and I think it’s amazing!’
  • ‘Oooofff at least wipe the rim. Looks like smokers phlegm’
  • ‘I thought I would dislike the imitation Vegemite. What a surprise!’
  • ‘To me it does not taste like vegemite’


If you want to give it a spin, here’s the recipe:

  • 70 grams Black Tahini Paste
  • 50 grams tamari sauce
  • 1 tbsn nutritional yeast flakes
  • 1 tspn apple cider vinegar

Add all ingredients to the Thermomix mixing bowl and mix for 20 seconds on speed 3.

Use spatula to scoop paste out and store in a glass jar in the fridge.

Want more? Listen to this best bit from Jonesy & Amanda!