Billy Joel’s Tuesday night concert at New York City’s Madison Square Garden featured a couple of treats: guest appearances by his pals Sting and John Mellencamp. Sting joined Billy to perform a duet on Billy’s 1986 song, “Big Man on Mulberry Street.” Sting sang that same song earlier this month as a tribute to Billy at the ASCAP Centennial Awards. Mellecamp, meanwhile, took the stage to sing his hit “Crumblin’ Down,” while Billy backed him up. The entire set list is posted on The show was Billy’s 11th at the Garden since he started his once-a-month residency there in January. He already has shows scheduled through July 1 of 2015. If he plays it, that show will break the record for most concerts by a single act at the legendary New York venue: it’ll be his 65th career show there. Hit play to see John Mellencamp perform Crumbling Down with Billy Joel playing.

Want more? Listen to this best bit from Jonesy & Amanda!